- last post: 01.01.0001 12:00 AM PDT
A really nice theroy, but I have some questions and some critisim(sp?). First, I will be a critic. I know and I can see that you have lots of supporting evidence, of something else though. It sounds like your trying to say that Marathon and Halo are related and stuff(I dont wanna re-say the whole thing), but use stuff about mars. How does Mars work into this story? Could you explain how it does, if it does? I really want to believe your theroy, but I want too see more evidence, as do many of the other people. I just will say it in a formal and nice way, which you deserve. All I want is some clairification and evidence.
Did you ever think that the Halo universe and Marathon Universe are the same? I ask this becasue it never really says or shows in Halo 3 that they are in another universe. When watching the Cartographer cutscene with Spark and Chief, you see that they were at the edge of the galaxy and on the Ark. So, they haven't traveled to another universe going the Portal initially. I can support this with saying the Forerunners had only covered the extent of their galaxy, not a universe. In a Server vid, not sure witch one, they talk about the flood being extra-galactic, being from another galaxy. If the Forerunners had covered the universe, they would have come by this galaxy before the Flood found them. I want to go back and look for a quote from the books, but I'm too damn lazy and will another time.
How do we still know they are on the edge of the Galaxy, durring the cutscene we see debris from the destroyed Ark and Halo. Unless that escaped into another universe too, they must be close or remain where they are at. And, even though the portal was an alternate dimension, it couldn't have lead anywhere else besides that galaxy because of the made-up Slip-Space laws.