- x Foman123 x
- |
- Master Forum Ninja
- gamertag: [none]
- user homepage:
Posted by: paulmarv
Posted by: furiocity
In response to Foman
Your idea sounds feasible, although I ask, how would you go about gaining access to such a forum? Would it be mythic members only? Legendary and up? Heroic and up? This has no credibility coming from the likes of me, but what about the group of people that can make good posts, but have made too many mistakes before, and thus have doomed their trust ratings? What about them? Do you think there should be an application of some sort for said members?
That is indeed a good point. Maybe if a certain number of Mythic members agree, a normal member can be accepted, or something along those lines. I know lots of good, intelligent, constructive community members that are just members, including myself and you.
Little things like that could be solved, but the debate lies in the general idea. I've already stated in detail why this is a good idea and why I support it.Yeah, agreed with paulmarv. Hopefully, if anything remotely like this idea ever comes into play (at this point, it's all academic, but at least it's a good discussion), there would be a way to sort out the details and find ways to get regular members into the restricted-posting forum who are clearly both active and able to post within forum rules. I don't like the idea of any kind of subjective filter, as it leaves too much room for unfairness and bias, but at the end of the day it could be the best solution. Another potential solution could be to lower the automatic requirements to become a Heroic Member.
Regardless, though, I can see how your question would go towards the overall issue of whether such a forum would even be a good idea in the first place, which is where the focus of my various posts lies :-)