- last post: 01.01.0001 12:00 AM PDT
I, for one, have gotten sick of numerous people posting the same topic, fighting for the same theory, without useful evidence. So here, use these guidelines and you theory will be better received, you will convince more people, and you gain respect.
1) Use proper English when typing. Don't cut words short, like typing u for you. Only use caps where it is grammatically correct, or when stressing a couple of words. It ticks people off when your whole post is in caps. Use commas, periods, and spaces where need. Finally, proof-read what you wrote. Make sure it is in a logical order, meaning every 'A' has a 'B', every 'First' has a 'Second.'
2) Search for your topic. Cheack the first three-four pages, and make sure someone hasn't posted that already. If someone has, skim through, and before you add to it make sure you are not adding what someone already has. I know that everyone wants to post and be thought of as smart for pointing something out, but when every other post says the same thing it gets boring.
3) Research. Before posting a new theory, research it. Read the books, they help a lot. Try to find information in other theories that you can use. Compile your information into a brainstorm, and from there make a guide to follow when typing it up.
4) CITE YOUR INFORMATION. The worst theories to read are the ones where there are no cites to the books, games, or other posts. If you want to be believed, cite. It is that simple. Citing your sources is as simple as this. "Blah blah blah blah blah blah." (The Fall of Reach p. 1034.) If you are using information found in the game, state the level. If your information is found here in a post, state the name of the topic, page number it is on, and the author. Give credit where credit is due.
5) Have an open mind. Although this isn't directly related to posting a good theory, it is related to how people view you after posting your theory. Encourage people to try to find holes in your theory. If someone does, go back and look at the problem area. Come up with more information backing your view, not the same stuff over and over.
An example of a good theory is Eagle 117's, called "the most conclusive theory ever." (or something like that?) In it he gives a sound, well typed, researched, and cited arguement supporting his theory. He had an open mind, and invited people to find the holes in his theory.
Now, I know I am probably missing something, so if I am jsut pm me and I will add it where it should fit. So read this, use it, and many of us here at the bungie forums will respect you and look forward to reading your work.
-Also, this applies to any post being made. Although some parts might not, some do. Always use good English, check to make sure it is a NEW idea or topic, and KEEP AN OPEN MIND!!!
Good luck!
-Erls
[Edited on 7/14/2004 9:11:48 AM]