- SweetTRIX
- |
- Exalted Mythic Member
Doc: "i'm a pacifist"
Caboose: "your a thing that babies suck on?"
Tucker: "no dude, that's a pedephile"
Church: "tucker, i think he means a pacifier"
Posted by: matt05891
Posted by: SweetTRIX
Posted by: matt05891
I'm also lost as to why people have trouble believing its Sam, Kelly,John,Fred, and Linda. Like the only one possibly wrong is Sam, if you read the books you glance at it and are like oh yea I see. But people fight everything I suppose
Because that is an assumption all on it's own, and a poor one if you've read the books. Your talking about taking the trailer for what it is, and not overcomplicating, ok lets simplify. We see Reach under seige, what do we know, that MC and Linda weren't on the planet. That being said, why would they be on the banner? There needs to be an explanation, and when an explanation is needed, but not provided, theories pop up. Not everyone likes to take the easy way, there is no right or wrong. Though there certainly are theories that are rediclous, there are also some really good ones.
True, and I like how you look at it. But people forget that they participated in Reach's defense to destroy a NAV database. Technically they were in the battle even if there weren't on planet. They just left when PoA Jumped to escape being destroyed. And my theory is that it is them. Linda the Sniper, then the first sentence in First Strike is " spartan *** Fredrick twirled his combat knife" or something like that so I would think the one would be Fred, Then John was the leader of the group, and the leader of Blue team which consisted of those mentioned. Then Kelly the fastest spartan would have no weapons for she is a would be a scout and they lost there weapons when they had to abandon ship when the driver of the pelican was killed and they had to jump. Then there's Sam who was stated in the book to be a head taller then John and was a heavy weapons expert. I dont see how its a poor assumption if I read the books... ( just defending myself :p )
There is no need, I was not attacking your theory, simply stating that many question theories out of their curiosity born from their appreciation and understanding of the story. Personally since I feel Reach will cover more than just the ground engagement on Reach, I agree that John and Linda are most likely the center and sniper soldiers depicted. Sam was dead long before that engagement, so it most likely isn't him, but who knows. My true want for this game is to cover engagements from the beginning of the Spartans training all the way through the loss of Reach.