- Shai Hulud
- |
- Exalted Mythic Member
With B.B. gone, the passion of Bungie.net has lessened.
Try and rate the movie as a movie. If you rate it as a movie based on a book, then it will always suck, because movie-makers always do that to books.... The same thing happened with Frank Herbert's Dune... The movie and the miniseries all butchered the book pretty well, in my opinion.... but, as movies and miniseries, they were good.
I've never read "I, Robot" (wasn't it several short stories, not actually a novel?), but the movie turned out to be the second-best movie I've ever seen (the only thing that beats it is The Matrix).