Halo: Reach Forum
This topic has moved here: Subject: We might be wrong(THEORY)
  • Subject: We might be wrong(THEORY)
Subject: We might be wrong(THEORY)

Ok what if the planet in the ending of Halo 3 is Reach. When the Ark went bam what happened to the few hundred that werent killed off already, well MOST of them died. What about Sgt. Jonhson. What if that he did survive the ark goin boom and found a ship of somesort that he could use to rescue the remaining marins nearby and leave 04(II) go throu with MC and then end up on Reach. That might be how the game goes, MC jonhson and some unknown Marines fight on the glassed Reach and kill some thousand covenant that were left there when they exscaped for Unkown places. So that is my theory, you guys like?

  • 08.26.2009 4:50 AM PDT

No, I don't like.

For starters, Johnson is dead. If Spark didn't kill him, then the giant fall off the platform did. If the fall didn't kill him, then the explosion did. There's no possible way he could have survived.

Second, MC, Arbiter, and Johnson were the only ones to land on the ring, so I don't know who exactly Johnson would rescue if he was even alive. I also have no idea what ship he would actually be flying. The ring isn't even finished yet, why would some random spaceship be there (and who would it be made for?)

Now, your theory is going off of what the ending to Halo 3 brought, but it goes against what Bungie has stated Reach to be, not to mention the trailer for it. Reach is a prequel, so stuff like that hasn't happened yet.

  • 08.26.2009 4:57 AM PDT

Just enjoy the damn game!
Who cares about BR vs AR

1) Johnson didn't die on the Ark. He died on the Halo which exploded. He was in the centre of the explosion, which most likely destroyed the Ark as well.
2) *Facepalm*... How unlikely is it that the journey from Earth to the Ark passes directly past Reach?
3) You couldn't fight on a glassed planet. There would be nothing there! No terrain to speak of, no greenery, no rivers, no oceans, perhaps even no atmosphere! It would become a dead planet.
4) Sorry, I hate being a complete -blam!- but all your ideas and theories are extremely unlikely.

  • 08.26.2009 5:00 AM PDT