- gamertag: [none]
- user homepage:
Member of Bungie.net for nearly three years, still continuing!
Enjoy what you have and live on.
My gamertag is Elder Bias
Posted by: OrderedComa
Posted by: grey101
Posted by: OrderedComa
Posted by: raganok99
Sorry, but you're wrong.
Halsey's Journal and marketing material has fixed VERY little the errors of Halo Reach. And marketing material is rated as third, according to canon "rules". Game being first and novels being second in canon "rules". Market material does not override the canon.
There's some content in the game is canon-breaking such as wrong timeline, PoA being on ground which it is impossible due to massive weight and consider about laws of physics applied to it too. And Halycon-class cruisers or Marathon-Class cruisers or larger ships ARE NOT rated for atmosphere. You may argue that PoA went on Halo but it was not case. They were forced to land down since they suffered massive damage from fighting against battle-group of CCS battle-cruisers.
Spartan-IIIs were fine with me for now.
And it does "conflict" the novels of The Fall of Reach, First Strike and little bit of Ghost of Onyx.
Some things in Reach can be simply retconned, but others can't be retconned so simply, it would require to re-write novels.
Actually no I'm not. A lot of the "errors" are no longer errors because the Journal and the marketing materials for Reach have explained them, thus making them no longer errors.
You are overlooking the key detail of canon ranking, marketing materials make take a space below the books and games, but that's only if old marketing material conflicts with something new. New marketing material for a new game will take priority over information for an older game or book.
you are wrong because the journal didn't explain anything other than halsey that NOBLE team were ONI spartans and that cortana had a certain part of her copied to study the crystal.
o0o it also said that miranda was halseys daughter.
That is all the journal explained so i wish you would stop spreading the idea that it "fixed" everything because it didn't. If you actually had the journal and could read it you would know this but you don't so stop it.
I don't think I have ever said it fixed everything, I said it fixes a lot of the issues, and I mentioned the marketing materials as well. They fix much more together than separate.
Again, no. It did not fix most issues caused by the Halo Reach game. It only fixed very little in the game.
Marketing material will not override that canon because in rules of canon setting, marketing material is rated as third. It doesn't grant that marketing material to override it. Sorry, but no. You're wrong again.