Bungie Universe
This topic has moved here: Subject: star destroyer vs assault carrier
  • Subject: star destroyer vs assault carrier
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • of 2
Subject: star destroyer vs assault carrier
  •  | 
  • Honorable Member

No,no,no neither...
The Battle Barge, Octavius of the Ultramarines imperium fleet would, without a doubt wipe out both ships.
This ship carries shields so strong that it can repel gamma radiation and still have enough armaments to be equivalent to 3 SUPER MAC or a covenant glass Beam, that can be easily aimed at other ships via forward spinning lazz turrets that concentrate the beam into a powerful blast.
Ultramarines FTW!

  • 11.02.2010 8:43 PM PDT
  •  | 
  • Honorable Member

Fair enough, now how bout Vader's SUPER STAR DESTROYER remember that? the ship that dwarfed all other star destroyers and made them look like frigates? If you would measure a Super carrier to a star destroyer it would make it look small, yes, but two or three could still destroy that Super carrier (star wars technology was more advanced than human technology so its only logical to say that star destroyers could put up a better fight).
Now the SUPER STAR DESTROYER that made other star destroyers look like ants vs The SUPER CARRIER that is considerably larger than a normal star destroyer but DOES NOT dwarf it.


SUPER STAR DESTROYER FTW.
Larger ship.
Stronger shields.
More room for fighters/bombers.
Bigger/stronger guns.

  • 11.02.2010 8:49 PM PDT

Posted by: armourlockftw
Colonol Shepard FTW! What do you think about Stargate Universe?


Should never have been aired.

More like BSG than Stargate.

Also, apparently in the 2nd season, the Lucian Alliance is planning an attack on Earth. EARTH. I swear, the new leader of the LA is off his rocker. Nine 304s + AT-FLIPPING-LANTIS + All the new tech the Lantean database gave us [We might be able to build ZPMs now...]=roflpwnage on ANYTHING the LA could send at Earth, or any other Tau'ri allied world. Hell, we could curbstomp the COVENANT!

  • 11.03.2010 11:53 AM PDT

Posted by: t5yfm
No,no,no neither...
The Battle Barge, Octavius of the Ultramarines imperium fleet would, without a doubt wipe out both ships.
This ship carries shields so strong that it can repel gamma radiation and still have enough armaments to be equivalent to 3 SUPER MAC or a covenant glass Beam, that can be easily aimed at other ships via forward spinning lazz turrets that concentrate the beam into a powerful blast.
Ultramarines FTW!


UH, WH40K has been banned from this discussion, and from the Halo/Stargate forums in general.

BTW, Ascendancy class vessel>>>>your ship.

  • 11.03.2010 11:54 AM PDT

Super carrier.

  • 11.03.2010 12:18 PM PDT

I'm not sure where people are getting Super Carrier when the OP clearly says Assault Carrier vs I-Class Star Destroyer (the ones commonly seen in the original films).

From what I recall Star Wars Turbo lasers are significantly shorter in range than the main gun on an Assault Carrier and am fairly certain the max listed acceleration is due to it accelerating to light speed.

[Edited on 11.03.2010 1:55 PM PDT]

  • 11.03.2010 1:55 PM PDT

damn, thought you said death star, almost called you an idiot.

eh, would be good fight; the carrier can snipe ships and is more maneuverable, but the destroyer has good shields.

I really don't know.

  • 11.03.2010 3:43 PM PDT


Posted by: t5yfm
Fair enough, now how bout Vader's SUPER STAR DESTROYER remember that? the ship that dwarfed all other star destroyers and made them look like frigates? If you would measure a Super carrier to a star destroyer it would make it look small, yes, but two or three could still destroy that Super carrier (star wars technology was more advanced than human technology so its only logical to say that star destroyers could put up a better fight).
Now the SUPER STAR DESTROYER that made other star destroyers look like ants vs The SUPER CARRIER that is considerably larger than a normal star destroyer but DOES NOT dwarf it.


SUPER STAR DESTROYER FTW.
Larger ship.
Stronger shields.
More room for fighters/bombers.
Bigger/stronger guns.


fail.

The Executor destroyer was 8 Kilometers shorter then the Covenant Supercarrier (19 km to 27 km)

The Supercarrier is the largest and most powerful warship I've ever heard of, it could swat the Destroyer like a fly (possibly a hyperbole, but still)

  • 11.03.2010 3:47 PM PDT

Yes, I'm a furry. And yes, I like men. So what?


Posted by: MATTRC38
would a covenant assault carrier vs a imperial I-class star destroyer from star wars would win in a battle?
Personaly I think the star destroyer would win because of its massive armament of 60 turbolasers, 60 ion cannons, 6 dual heavy turbolaser turrets, 2 dual heavy ion cannon turrets, 2 heavy quad turbolasers, three triple medium turbolasers, and 10 tractor beams. Plus 72 TIE fighters and bombers, are a lot of firepower.


And the Covenant Assault Carrier could be upgraded with an energy lance - it would cut the Star Destroyer in half in a matter of, let's say, ten seconds?

  • 11.03.2010 3:52 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Haha mastercheif comes out of no were from halo 2 with covie's bomb throws bomb in big explosion the end XD

  • 12.30.2010 12:27 PM PDT

Edit: Holy -blam!-! I forgot I posted here before! How did this thread come back?

Anyway:

Assault Carrier.

It is impossible to not notice the two obviously exposed shield generators. Destroy them with Plasma Torpedoes/pulse laser barrages and then cut the Destroyer in half with Projectors.

That and pretty much all Covie ships are far more maneuverable then Star Destroyers.

"Now the SUPER STAR DESTROYER that made other star destroyers look like ants vs The SUPER CARRIER that is considerably larger than a normal star destroyer but DOES NOT dwarf it."

Supercarrier=27 km

SSD=19 km


SUPER STAR DESTROYER FTW.
"Larger ship."=already disproved
"Stronger shields."an obviously exposed shield generator that can be destroyed with a couple of shots
"More room for fighters/bombers."=true, 'cept pulse lasers would vaporize fighters before they got close enough to to serious damage.
"Bigger/stronger guns."=how? The explosion from an SSD cannon is no bigger then a few tons of TNT, whereas Energy Projectors are estimated to fire at 20 kilotons per second.

Its got MORE guns, but not more POWERFUL guns.

Besides, the reactor in Star Destroyers sits in the second most obvious point on the ship: the Brdge (Hence the A-Wing from Episode 6 taking out a SSD by ramming it).

Frankly, SW ships kinda suck (at lest Imperial ones do)

[Edited on 12.30.2010 12:47 PM PST]

  • 12.30.2010 12:32 PM PDT


Posted by: countrychris369

Posted by: Dawkinsfan33

Posted by: MATTRC38
would a covenant assault carrier vs a imperial I-class star destroyer from star wars would win in a battle?
Personaly I think the star destroyer would win because of its massive armament of 60 turbolasers, 60 ion cannons, 6 dual heavy turbolaser turrets, 2 dual heavy ion cannon turrets, 2 heavy quad turbolasers, three triple medium turbolasers, and 10 tractor beams. Plus 72 TIE fighters and bombers, are a lot of firepower.


also: the force


This is why the Star Destoryer would win


because, you know, ALL SW ships have the force.

-______________________________-

  • 12.30.2010 12:40 PM PDT

RIP - The Rev: February 9, 1981 – December 28, 2009
RIP - Mitch Lucker: October 20, 1984 - November 1, 2012
RIP - Dimebag Darrell: August 20, 1966 – December 8, 2004
RIP - Ronny James Dio: July 10, 1942 - May 16, 2010

Some pictures would be appreciated.

Waste of metal.

Super weapon, anybody?

CAS. Done.

  • 12.30.2010 12:47 PM PDT

Escalators don't break, they just become stairs.


Posted by: armourlockftw
That depends on the type of anti matter

Halo 2 cario station anti-matter

  • 12.30.2010 2:57 PM PDT

Escalators don't break, they just become stairs.

The Assault Carrier could use tactical slipspace jumps to avoid shots, regroup and recharge plasma. AC also has hurogok that can help repair the ships engines and guns.

  • 12.30.2010 3:01 PM PDT

Join the Outer Haven group!

Personally I think the Star Destroyer would win, but I know the Covenant can't possibly damage the Sun Crusher and would stand no chance against a Yuzhan Vong ship.

  • 12.30.2010 7:51 PM PDT

  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • of 2