Bungie Universe
This topic has moved here: Subject: Citadel Fleet (Mass Effect) VS UNSC (Halo)
  • Subject: Citadel Fleet (Mass Effect) VS UNSC (Halo)
Subject: Citadel Fleet (Mass Effect) VS UNSC (Halo)


Posted by: KSI SC Matt
Posted by: ROBERTO jh

Posted by: KSI SC Matt
Think about it this way- if a single Reaper w/triple-digit kiloton level weapons could literally stop the Citadel and Alliance fleets cold, what could a UNSC frigate-or a battlegroup-do?



MAC salvo and or double digit megaton nuclear warhead.


>.>

That statement was supposed to be PRO Halo.
I meant that if one Reaper could savage both the Citadel and Alliance fleets, the UNSC and it's MANY frigates would more or less turn the collective forces of the Systems Alliance and the Citadel into a Charlie Foxtrot massacre.


sorry, just didn't sound that way the way I read it... *facepalms self...again*

  • 12.08.2010 9:20 AM PDT

Wake me when the jews are gone.

it would be lihe the 7 days war UNSC=Israel

  • 12.08.2010 11:59 AM PDT


Posted by: ROBERTO jh

Posted by: Archon170
You better hope the Alliance fleet win against the UNSC, otherwise they won't stand a chance against the Reapers.


so 1,200,000,000,000,000 kiloton bombs, 59 gigaton super MACs, energy beams such as pulse lasers, 68 per-shot standardized Frigate MACs (already superior to almost all of the highest powered weapons in ME) Slip-Space cannons and Spartans can't destroy Reapers?

But inferior technology can? Interesting...

And since the Reapers are suddenly allowed in, so are the Covenant, who have weapons that bypass kinetic barriers used by the Reapers and would therefore be able to one shot any Reaper with a plasma torpedo (and have ships 26 km longer then Sovereign; more ship surface=more weapons and bigger reactor)

Alliance alone cannot possible win from UNSC, that is a fact. The Alliance has only 8 Dreadnoughts (which I would like the remind you are the only ships that actually have any chance against UNSC), their fleet is only 200 ships big (which means Earth has 100 SMACs more then the Alliance has ships) vs UNSC's 2000 warships alone, hell Alliance is privetly funded, they simply don't have the funds for a war with an Empire like the UNSC.

Fancy looking inferior technology, you can't forget about the most important part! It's all because of the flying cars!

Actually Precursors are Halo's equilvent of the Reapers (as the mysterious ancient super race, not the genocidal squid-ships) which is pretty much like an instant win button for us...


It's funny how good the Halo Effect Trailer works, it still does make sense...
Change Shapard to Chief, Reapers to Flood, Collectors to the Covenant (Loyalists) and Omega 4 Relay to the Portal of Voi and voila, I present you with a Halo 3 trailer! xD

  • 12.08.2010 2:48 PM PDT

Sir Arch-Duke Ferdinand II Jr. Sr. III Phd.

Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.


LOLWUT

  • 12.08.2010 3:01 PM PDT


Posted by: GeorgeBaggy
Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.


LOLWUT

ME fanboy logic:
Technology that wouldn't exist without a magical element = grounded in reality
Technology that is theoretically possible, so it has no flying cars = unrealstic BS

[Edited on 12.08.2010 3:10 PM PST]

  • 12.08.2010 3:10 PM PDT


Posted by: Vercetti24

Posted by: ROBERTO jh

Posted by: Archon170
You better hope the Alliance fleet win against the UNSC, otherwise they won't stand a chance against the Reapers.


so 1,200,000,000,000,000 kiloton bombs, 59 gigaton super MACs, energy beams such as pulse lasers, 68 per-shot standardized Frigate MACs (already superior to almost all of the highest powered weapons in ME) Slip-Space cannons and Spartans can't destroy Reapers?

But inferior technology can? Interesting...

And since the Reapers are suddenly allowed in, so are the Covenant, who have weapons that bypass kinetic barriers used by the Reapers and would therefore be able to one shot any Reaper with a plasma torpedo (and have ships 26 km longer then Sovereign; more ship surface=more weapons and bigger reactor)

Alliance alone cannot possible win from UNSC, that is a fact. The Alliance has only 8 Dreadnoughts (which I would like the remind you are the only ships that actually have any chance against UNSC), their fleet is only 200 ships big (which means Earth has 100 SMACs more then the Alliance has ships) vs UNSC's 2000 warships alone, hell Alliance is privetly funded, they simply don't have the funds for a war with an Empire like the UNSC.

Fancy looking inferior technology, you can't forget about the most important part! It's all because of the flying cars!

Actually Precursors are Halo's equilvent of the Reapers (as the mysterious ancient super race, not the genocidal squid-ships) which is pretty much like an instant win button for us...


It's funny how good the Halo Effect Trailer works, it still does make sense...
Change Shapard to Chief, Reapers to Flood, Collectors to the Covenant (Loyalists) and Omega 4 Relay to the Portal of Voi and voila, I present you with a Halo 3 trailer! xD


now THAT was a trailer!

  • 12.08.2010 3:21 PM PDT

Sir Arch-Duke Ferdinand II Jr. Sr. III Phd.

Posted by: Vercetti24

Posted by: GeorgeBaggy
Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.


LOLWUT

ME fanboy logic:
Technology that wouldn't exist without a magical element = grounded in reality
Technology that is theoretically possible, so it has no flying cars = unrealstic BS


couldn't sum it up any better. Mass Effect is incredible sci-fi, but there is no such thing as Mass Effect in real life

  • 12.08.2010 3:26 PM PDT


Posted by: ROBERTO jh

Posted by: Vercetti24
It's funny how good the Halo Effect Trailer works, it still does make sense...
Change Shapard to Chief, Reapers to Flood, Collectors to the Covenant (Loyalists) and Omega 4 Relay to the Portal of Voi and voila, I present you with a Halo 3 trailer! xD


now THAT was a trailer!


There was another one that actually looked better, but Johnson sintead of being the deadliest he was Jacob and that's just an insult to Johnson.
Why you might ask? Mainly because of this

  • 12.08.2010 3:28 PM PDT


Posted by: GeorgeBaggy
Posted by: Vercetti24

Posted by: GeorgeBaggy
Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.


LOLWUT

ME fanboy logic:
Technology that wouldn't exist without a magical element = grounded in reality
Technology that is theoretically possible, so it has no flying cars = unrealstic BS


couldn't sum it up any better. Mass Effect is incredible sci-fi, but there is no such thing as Mass Effect in real life

Atleast if they explained the effects of Eezo, but noooo, that's too much, now its just magic.
But still in most vs battles ME fanboys are ususally the ones that compare everything to RL, totally ignoring the fact that their entire universe is based on magic.

The true reason why there's magic in ME is because Bioware was previously mainly making classic WRPGs, not only they cannot let go of magic, they have to do it to appeal to their fanbase.

  • 12.08.2010 3:37 PM PDT

your overlooking the fact that both sides have already adapted there sheilds/tech to not be effected by megnetosphere and the weapons on the ME ships do change there aiming to hit the target against the captains orders while the UNSC has to manually make corrections or wait for the AI meaning that the only difference of fighting above a celestial body would be slower firing rate for the UNSC and ME ships

  • 12.08.2010 5:10 PM PDT

you raff you ruse (ME fanboy stop trying you know ME would lose)

  • 12.08.2010 5:17 PM PDT

oh by the way ME DOES NOT have power armour if anything there armour is plastic with a thin tin core while even the UNSC marines have thick peices of military grade steel with bullet proof layers underneath AND they arn't like those weak ME marines who get scared if a rock rolls down a hill at them (this isn't even counting the spartans who are more armoured then a tank and have no fear, they replaced that with muscle to break your neck and use it as a necklace). plus everyone in ME looks like they had too much plastic surgery to look like anime characters

  • 12.08.2010 5:27 PM PDT

THOSE -blam!- CALIBRATIONS
Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.

Just the CAIN itself could vaporize dozens of Hunters with a single slug, and that's not even going into detail about the Reaper fleet's armaments.

And the Destiny Ascension, that thing could rip apart any Covenant/UNSC ship with little effort.

Also Garrus, Garrus could take on the whole Covenant armada by himself and still have time by the end of the day to finish those calibrations.

  • 12.09.2010 2:35 AM PDT


Posted by: SCARFACE71795
THOSE -blam!- CALIBRATIONS
Posted by: Reptilian Rob
Mass Effect tech is ridiculous, plain and simple. It's grounded in reality, whereas Halo's is not.

Just the CAIN itself could vaporize dozens of Hunters with a single slug, and that's not even going into detail about the Reaper fleet's armaments.

And the Destiny Ascension, that thing could rip apart any Covenant/UNSC ship with little effort.

Also Garrus, Garrus could take on the whole Covenant armada by himself and still have time by the end of the day to finish those calibrations.

No, THOSE -blam!- DELUSIONAL ME FANBOYS

Garrus and his calibrations show again how incompetent they are, the entire time he is calibrating, why can't the AI do it?

  • 12.09.2010 3:45 AM PDT

Wake me when the jews are gone.

the EDI one of the most advanced ME AI's is a dumb AI need more

  • 12.09.2010 6:34 AM PDT

Wake me when the jews are gone.

the war would be like these
1th day: a UNSC refifted colony ship arrives at a council sistem the 4 frigates atack, the UNSC makes quick work of them and call for reinforcments. after losing contact the council send 3 cruiser to investigate. only one cruiser come back badly damaged they say that a human aliance with superb firepower easily destroyed their ships and their name was UNSC the council repleis in the news: yes the UNSC a human alliance with superb firepower that atacked our colony we dismissed that claim
2th day: the ONI steal a ship and send a message confirming their existance and calling for the citadel surrender the council thinks in seding a fleet but don't send because it could start a war at terminus sistem.
3th day: after several colonies disband the council send a fleet of 1 dreadnought 4 cruisers and 8 frigates against 1 marathon 5 frigates and 4 destroyers the fleet is destroyed with medium losses to the UNSC Cerberus join the UNSC.
4th day: the council send shepard's team to the sistem a longsword destroy the engines, noble and read teams board the normandy killing most of its crew and capturing shepard's team. One AI's steal the ship data and discover about the mass relays.
5th day: the UNSC begins destroying the mass relays and capturing sistems the council begins sending fleets to protect their sistems and have it's fisrt win
6th day: the UNSC make contact with the geth and arrange an aliance, the batarians and merc bands start atacking UNSC controled space.
7th day: the UNSC send an fleet of over a 50 ships that make easy work of the citadel defense fleet but they lock the citadel to all the UNSC
8th day the ONI infiltrate 3 spartam teams ho capture the council and force their surrender
Over the next weekthe UNSC eliminate the resistance

  • 12.09.2010 2:30 PM PDT

stop reposting the same thing

  • 12.09.2010 5:12 PM PDT

ODST's kick ass! -blam!-in...

I respect the fact that you are a hardcore mass effect and halo fan, but you talk as if this is actually real. You do know these are just video games right? Games forged by the imaginations of people. So when you say "Mass Effect soldiers use kinetic barriers, rather than energy shielding. Covenant plasma and energy weapons wouldn't be hindered by these at all." To me sounds extremely ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, I am also an uber nerd, but really? Live in the real world man and get a life.

  • 12.10.2010 12:53 AM PDT

MJOLNIR Mark VII in Reach! We can make it happen!!!

Just thought of something; The Reapers versus the Flood.

  • 12.10.2010 4:58 AM PDT


Posted by: BRAWLER117
I respect the fact that you are a hardcore mass effect and halo fan, but you talk as if this is actually real. You do know these are just video games right? Games forged by the imaginations of people. So when you say "Mass Effect soldiers use kinetic barriers, rather than energy shielding. Covenant plasma and energy weapons wouldn't be hindered by these at all." To me sounds extremely ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, I am also an uber nerd, but really? Live in the real world man and get a life.


eh, we're just having fun, but I'm getting bored of this discussion too; it was established 4 pages ago Halo would destroy ME, but Fsabran over there keeps trying to desperately keep it alive.

Or is that who're you're talking about?

Still, someone needs to let this thread die...

  • 12.10.2010 5:22 AM PDT

If you're not dead, you're fine. It's when you're dying that you need to worry.

I don't understand the obsession with just talking about the ships of the two fleets. Both are made up of ground forces as well. Why not discuss the event of a ground based operation that pits the Citadel Fleets troops against the Marines from the UNSC? We're obviously not going to come to a concensus about a ship-to-ship fight so why not move on?

  • 12.10.2010 5:27 AM PDT

ya so lets get it started. Alright UNSC ground forces would win the engagments depending on what units were deployed and how many. while the ME troops would be fairly uniform in their performance. pretty much the UNSC marines would have a fairly hard time with the ME troops seeing as they can chuck them around while the ODSTs would think it was a joke fighting guys who hide behind kinetic barriers rather then fight like the men the UNSC is composed of. Then we go into the spartans who wouldnt even break a sweat ripping the ME ranks apart and laying them out "break it, section it off, lay them out" and the ME troops would be more or less defensless to the spartan onslaught. thats pretty much a spartans day anyway so it wouldn't be considered anything but target practise for them. I do want to here replys from the ME dude

  • 12.10.2010 12:56 PM PDT


Posted by: egore11
Citadel Fleet Vs UNSC Fleet

Citadel Wins.

Citadel Fleet vs Covenant Fleet

Citadel Wins with major losses

Citadel Fleet Vs Forerunner

Forerunners do not loose a single piece of metal

Reapers vs Forerunners

Forerunners win with few losses

Prothean other Ancient Mass Effect Races vs Forerunners

Forerunners win with large losses, but recover quickly

Everything vs Percussors

Percussors obliterate them with one shot, defying everything physics, and then rip through the dimensions. As they are Tier Zero, there unstoppable...they can create perfect life.


I was just reading through this thread, but my inner nerd will not stand this altercation and the temptation to join! The Reapers killed the Protheans. Every single one, not counting the ones who built a Mass Relay to the Citadel, which where killed by them eventually, indirectly. (Starvation, most likely.) The Reapers are beyond all the other races in the ME universe, and just one was only stopped after and entire fleet attacked it (with heavy losses) and it's shields where diverted, then brought down by Shepard. Reapers would tear apart almost any Halo vessel, and you can't use the 'We have Cortana!" argument either, Reapers are the ultimate state of being for A.I's, at least in the eyes of the Geth, which is a race composed entirely of A.I's. They are giant incarnations of what Cortona would be if she had a physical form that wasn't a hologram, only Reapers are better .

/Rant

Allright, my inner nerd has vented. Back to reading.

  • 12.10.2010 5:18 PM PDT


Posted by: Terrible Ideas

Posted by: egore11
Citadel Fleet Vs UNSC Fleet

Citadel Wins.

Citadel Fleet vs Covenant Fleet

Citadel Wins with major losses

Citadel Fleet Vs Forerunner

Forerunners do not loose a single piece of metal

Reapers vs Forerunners

Forerunners win with few losses

Prothean other Ancient Mass Effect Races vs Forerunners

Forerunners win with large losses, but recover quickly

Everything vs Percussors

Percussors obliterate them with one shot, defying everything physics, and then rip through the dimensions. As they are Tier Zero, there unstoppable...they can create perfect life.


I was just reading through this thread, but my inner nerd will not stand this altercation and the temptation to join! The Reapers killed the Protheans. Every single one, not counting the ones who built a Mass Relay to the Citadel, which where killed by them eventually, indirectly. (Starvation, most likely.) The Reapers are beyond all the other races in the ME universe, and just one was only stopped after and entire fleet attacked it (with heavy losses) and it's shields where diverted, then brought down by Shepard. Reapers would tear apart almost any Halo vessel, and you can't use the 'We have Cortana!" argument either, Reapers are the ultimate state of being for A.I's, at least in the eyes of the Geth, which is a race composed entirely of A.I's. They are giant incarnations of what Cortona would be if she had a physical form that wasn't a hologram, only Reapers are better .

/Rant

Allright, my inner nerd has vented. Back to reading.


my inner nerd compelled me to rejoin.

A Covenant Corvette could kill Sovereign. Why? He uses ONLY kinetic shields and Corvettes use ONLY energy weapons.

One well placed shot from the Corvette--the lightest warship in the Covenant fleet--could cripple or destroy Sovereign

As for a Supercarrier...or the Forerunners who could destroy stars with their ship weapons, don't even get me started at how quick Sovereign would be vaporized.

  • 12.10.2010 5:31 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

If you think nobody cares about you, miss some car payments.
Hard work never hurt anyone, but why take the chance.
The first sign of maturity is that the volume knob also turns to the left.

New Gamertag and profile: SHENANIGANS4780

Since it seems that the account didn't transfer, that's my new account everyone.

lol nova bomb...

Shoot it into the sun, slip space away from said sun.

Win.

  • 12.10.2010 7:23 PM PDT