- Plasma3150
- |
- Intrepid Legendary Member
Posted by: Wazooty
Posted by: Plasma3150
Posted by: Wazooty
Posted by: Plasma3150
Posted by: Wazooty
Unlike bungie, 343 doesn't ignore all previously established canon, they embrace it.According to Halsey's Journal, both the game and the book goes side-by-side.
do you honestly believe that the entirety of the unsc fleet that fought in the book was unaware reach was being invaded until the 30th? Half the planet was on fire weeks before that day.
Do you honestly believe that even though "60% of the unsc fleet" (as auntie dot said), that the POA and its members, one of the most high profile ships in the fleet with the most high profile ground forces in the unsc on board, were not aware of the fight for reach until 2 weeks after the rest of the universe knew?
You are daft.They were alerted, and they were indeed fighting. Auntie Dot said that the battle was on all fronts, both ground and orbital, in the Tip of the Spear opening cutscene.
You see, you are the daft one.
You are a fool. You stated that the books and the game go side by side, but then you decide to reference a part of the game that completely contradicts the book.
In the book they did not learn of reaches invasion until the 30th. In the game though they would've learned of it by the 15th at the latest.
Your argument is a total failure because you contradict your own statements. You are now double daft.Of course their will be some mild things changed.
If we went completely by the book, that would mean that the other books contradict it. Afterall, according to the Fall of Reach (Pg. 242, in fact), it states that we never encountered Sangheili before. That means Kurt's Mission Recording in Ghosts of Onyx is not cannon, as well with practically everything in Cole Protocol.