Bungie Universe
This topic has moved here: Poll [95 votes]: Spartans vs Jedi who wins the match?
  • Poll [95 votes]: Spartans vs Jedi who wins the match?
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • of 4
Subject: Spartans vs Jedi who wins the match?

Poll: Spartans vs Jedi who wins the match?  [closed]
Spartans:  43%
(41 Votes)
Jedi:  44%
(42 Votes)
Tie:  13%
(12 Votes)
Total Votes: 95

Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker agree to a virtual training excersize (nobody needs to die) with the UNSC and their Spartan Blue team.

Both jedi carry 1 lightsaber each, wear jedi robes, and are fully force capable.

The New improved Spartan Blue team, in wake of recent casualties, consists of...

John-117: MA5C, M99 Stanchion Gauss Rifle, M6G
Frederic-104: MA5C, Spartan Laser, M6G
Linda-058: BR55, SRS99D-S2 AM(sniper rifle), M6G
Kelly-087: Dual M7 Caseless, Rocket Launcher, M6G
Thel 'Vadam: Energy Sword, Carbine, plasma pistol

Each carries a standard issue weapon, a specialized weapon, a combat knife and a pistol.

I know the arbiter isn't a spartan, but the UNSC was desperate, so they recruited Thel by paying him in deep fried tuna fish, which he loves.

Can the New spartan team, Spartan Team PINK, beat the two jedi warriors, or are they doomed?

The Battle takes place in the Halo 3 map, The Pit

They will fight 10 matches, say who you think will win, for example, spartans win 6/10 matches etc.

  • 03.06.2011 5:54 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

Team Pink camps on the Sword room with Shotgun, Rocket Launcher and Sword until time runs out....Nah just kidding.

I don't know, hmmmmm it could be an even match.

  • 03.06.2011 5:56 PM PDT

Oh God, Chief with the M99 wil eviscerate at least one of those Jedi.

Its like a mini-MAC, I'd like to see them block that.

In fact, a lot of those weapons could easily kill a Jedi. Blocking a lead rond with your lightsaber will cause it to melt and burn your face.

  • 03.06.2011 6:01 PM PDT

I've heard sw fans claim that blocking a bullet makes the bullet vaporize instantly.

Blocking fire from a team of spratans and carbine shots from Thel would be impossible even for a jedi master however, so they would have to obviously take cover every now and again.

  • 03.06.2011 6:09 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

Well, Bullets are harder to block than lasers, since, well....The bullets are almost impossible to see once they've left the gun and lasers are red/blue and bright lights.

  • 03.06.2011 6:11 PM PDT


Posted by: xZcNx MarcWagz
I've heard sw fans claim that blocking a bullet makes the bullet vaporize instantly.

Blocking fire from a team of spratans and carbine shots from Thel would be impossible even for a jedi master however, so they would have to obviously take cover every now and again.


It would vaporize if it hit the blade of a lightsaber. I mean, if the bullet managed to withstand the heat and pass through it oh god would that hurt massively.

  • 03.06.2011 6:15 PM PDT

.

"Happiness is like glass, you might not always notice it but if you change your view and then that glass will sparkle when it reflects the light."

5 people vs two people. Its kinda obvious who would win. Linda would probably snipe both of them in a heart beat.

  • 03.06.2011 6:17 PM PDT

MJB

Spartans don't won't to get into a close range fight with Jedi (lightsaber equals dead spartan) and Jedi don't want to get stuck fighting Spartans from long range (bullets travel a lot faster than laser in star wars do, especially a hyper sonic sniper rifle bullet) it basically boils down to a manoeuvrings fight, who can find a good position first, who can back the other team into a position where they have the range advantage, who can force the other team the make a mistake first

  • 03.06.2011 6:19 PM PDT

It would make more sense if it was between an Elite and Jedi.

Elites would most likely come close but end up winning.
The Force is something that the Jedi has but it wouldn't do much good. Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.

Lets look at characteristics.

Elites
Height: 8'6
Strength: Kill in one simple punch or kick
Weight: 800 Pounds
Weaponry: Energy Sword and Energy Dagger

Jedi
Height: 6'0
Strength: Weak
Weight: 140 Pounds
Weaponry: Lightsaber

Lets say he gets the Elite and pulls him to him to be cut with the Lightsaber, Elites are much smarter than that and would take down the Jedi with him pulling out his dagger and stabbing him as he is getting stabbed.

Although this is very debatable. A Sword would come in contact with a Lightsaber and react just like another lightsaber. Another the Elite can extend much farther.

I'm putting my money on the Elites, just by sheer statistics.



  • 03.06.2011 6:19 PM PDT


Posted by: mojeda101
It would make more sense if it was between an Elite and Jedi.

Elites would most likely come close but end up winning.
The Force is something that the Jedi has but it wouldn't do much good. Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.

Lets look at characteristics.

Elites
Height: 8'6
Strength: Kill in one simple punch or kick
Weight: 800 Pounds
Weaponry: Energy Sword and Energy Dagger

Jedi
Height: 6'0
Strength: Weak
Weight: 140 Pounds
Weaponry: Lightsaber

Lets say he gets the Elite and pulls him to him to be cut with the Lightsaber, Elites are much smarter than that and would take down the Jedi with him pulling out his dagger and stabbing him as he is getting stabbed.

Although this is very debatable. A Sword would come in contact with a Lightsaber and react just like another lightsaber. Another the Elite can extend much farther.

I'm putting my money on the Elites, just by sheer statistics.

Spartans would probably win. Unless the Jedi used the force heavily to their advantage, like destroying the cover the Spartans have, and throwing each of them around like ragdolls. But each of those would leave them vulnerable to the other Spartans.

Anyways, why I quoted you:

1) Luke wasn't able to lift the X-wing out of the swamp because he wasn't trained in the Force yet, he was still learning. If you took a Master like Yoda in his prime, he could lift the X-wing and twirl it around like nothing.

2)An X-wing definitely weighs more than 1 tonne. A smart car weighs almost 1 tonne. A Jedi can certainly lift more than a smart car.

3) 800lbs is not 1 tonne. It's less than half a tonne. Not the same thing as an X-wing.

4) With the Force, a Jedi can lift much more weight than an Elite. Technically, he's stronger.

5) If an Elite is being pulled to a Jedi by Force, he may be smart enough to stab the Jedi, but he wouldn't be able to do it. He'd be dead before he charged his dagger.

6) In a one-on-one situation, the Jedi would kill an Elite before it could strike twice. The Jedi would know where the Elite was going to attack next, and beat him to it, then counter-attack.

  • 03.06.2011 6:34 PM PDT

MJB

elites may be phyically stronger and tougher than jedis but the force advantage isn't something to be underestimated, its not just the dark side that shouldn't be underestimated!

  • 03.06.2011 6:43 PM PDT

Posted by: Schulzy3

Posted by: mojeda101
It would make more sense if it was between an Elite and Jedi.

Elites would most likely come close but end up winning.
The Force is something that the Jedi has but it wouldn't do much good. Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.

Lets look at characteristics.

Elites
Height: 8'6
Strength: Kill in one simple punch or kick
Weight: 800 Pounds
Weaponry: Energy Sword and Energy Dagger

Jedi
Height: 6'0
Strength: Weak
Weight: 140 Pounds
Weaponry: Lightsaber

Lets say he gets the Elite and pulls him to him to be cut with the Lightsaber, Elites are much smarter than that and would take down the Jedi with him pulling out his dagger and stabbing him as he is getting stabbed.

Although this is very debatable. A Sword would come in contact with a Lightsaber and react just like another lightsaber. Another the Elite can extend much farther.

I'm putting my money on the Elites, just by sheer statistics.

Spartans would probably win. Unless the Jedi used the force heavily to their advantage, like destroying the cover the Spartans have, and throwing each of them around like ragdolls. But each of those would leave them vulnerable to the other Spartans.

Anyways, why I quoted you:

1) Luke wasn't able to lift the X-wing out of the swamp because he wasn't trained in the Force yet, he was still learning. If you took a Master like Yoda in his prime, he could lift the X-wing and twirl it around like nothing.

2)An X-wing definitely weighs more than 1 tonne. A smart car weighs almost 1 tonne. A Jedi can certainly lift more than a smart car.

3) 800lbs is not 1 tonne. It's less than half a tonne. Not the same thing as an X-wing.

4) With the Force, a Jedi can lift much more weight than an Elite. Technically, he's stronger.

5) If an Elite is being pulled to a Jedi by Force, he may be smart enough to stab the Jedi, but he wouldn't be able to do it. He'd be dead before he charged his dagger.

6) In a one-on-one situation, the Jedi would kill an Elite before it could strike twice. The Jedi would know where the Elite was going to attack next, and beat him to it, then counter-attack.


I never said 800IB was a ton. Where did I say that? You think a Jedi can lift massive weights with the force? Force Unleashed is not canon. A Master can barely lift a stack that was about to crush Anakin and Obi Wan. Its obvious a knight or Padawan is MUCH weaker.

Funny. You assume he wouldn't. It's a natural instinct.

That is a lie. Funny how 6000 Jedi can get killed by Clones. If they can't survive Clones, I hardly believe they would compete with the Covenant Elites which are MASSIVE. Incredibly strong and devoted to kill if it means taking their own life.

  • 03.06.2011 6:46 PM PDT

I guess it depends on the type of fight, but overall I would say the Spartan would.

  • 03.06.2011 6:50 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

I just play for fun. MLG can kiss my ass.


Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron

Posted by: xZcNx MarcWagz
I've heard sw fans claim that blocking a bullet makes the bullet vaporize instantly.

Blocking fire from a team of spratans and carbine shots from Thel would be impossible even for a jedi master however, so they would have to obviously take cover every now and again.


It would vaporize if it hit the blade of a lightsaber. I mean, if the bullet managed to withstand the heat and pass through it oh god would that hurt massively.


I'm a star wars fan and even I disagree on that. The bullet would melt, molten debris would fly everywhere, and the sheer amount of incoming bullets would render deflection null and void.

  • 03.06.2011 7:03 PM PDT

Et Eärello Endorenna utúlien.
Sinome maruvan ar Hildinyar.
tenn' Ambar-metta!

I'll go with Spartans, combat is their life, Jedis are monks, they might know how to use the force and a light saber, but fighting belongs to the Spartans.

  • 03.06.2011 7:05 PM PDT


Posted by: mojeda101
Posted by: Schulzy3

Posted by: mojeda101
It would make more sense if it was between an Elite and Jedi.

Elites would most likely come close but end up winning.
The Force is something that the Jedi has but it wouldn't do much good. Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.

Lets look at characteristics.

Elites
Height: 8'6
Strength: Kill in one simple punch or kick
Weight: 800 Pounds
Weaponry: Energy Sword and Energy Dagger

Jedi
Height: 6'0
Strength: Weak
Weight: 140 Pounds
Weaponry: Lightsaber

Lets say he gets the Elite and pulls him to him to be cut with the Lightsaber, Elites are much smarter than that and would take down the Jedi with him pulling out his dagger and stabbing him as he is getting stabbed.

Although this is very debatable. A Sword would come in contact with a Lightsaber and react just like another lightsaber. Another the Elite can extend much farther.

I'm putting my money on the Elites, just by sheer statistics.

Spartans would probably win. Unless the Jedi used the force heavily to their advantage, like destroying the cover the Spartans have, and throwing each of them around like ragdolls. But each of those would leave them vulnerable to the other Spartans.

Anyways, why I quoted you:

1) Luke wasn't able to lift the X-wing out of the swamp because he wasn't trained in the Force yet, he was still learning. If you took a Master like Yoda in his prime, he could lift the X-wing and twirl it around like nothing.

2)An X-wing definitely weighs more than 1 tonne. A smart car weighs almost 1 tonne. A Jedi can certainly lift more than a smart car.

3) 800lbs is not 1 tonne. It's less than half a tonne. Not the same thing as an X-wing.

4) With the Force, a Jedi can lift much more weight than an Elite. Technically, he's stronger.

5) If an Elite is being pulled to a Jedi by Force, he may be smart enough to stab the Jedi, but he wouldn't be able to do it. He'd be dead before he charged his dagger.

6) In a one-on-one situation, the Jedi would kill an Elite before it could strike twice. The Jedi would know where the Elite was going to attack next, and beat him to it, then counter-attack.


I never said 800IB was a ton. Where did I say that? You think a Jedi can lift massive weights with the force? Force Unleashed is not canon. A Master can barely lift a stack that was about to crush Anakin and Obi Wan. Its obvious a knight or Padawan is MUCH weaker.

Funny. You assume he wouldn't. It's a natural instinct.

That is a lie. Funny how 6000 Jedi can get killed by Clones. If they can't survive Clones, I hardly believe they would compete with the Covenant Elites which are MASSIVE. Incredibly strong and devoted to kill if it means taking their own life.

You said an Elite was like an X-wing.
Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.
Hardly any different.


You are under-estimating the Force, my friend. It wouldn't take much for a Jedi to throw a few Elite's to the ground.

  • 03.06.2011 7:11 PM PDT

"Find where the liar hides, so that I may place my boot between his gums!" - Rtas 'Vadum

Posted by: mojeda101
Elites:
Weight: 800 Pounds

318lbs

Sources: Bestiarium and Encyclopaedia. The only figure that has ever been given. Anything else is bollocks, because it does not exist.

  • 03.06.2011 7:20 PM PDT

Friends before pixels.

Spartans: 7/10 matches won. But, they take 36 casualties.
Jedi's: 3/10 matches won. 15 casualties.

If there were 5 jedi's, they would beat the crap out of Spartans.

  • 03.06.2011 7:28 PM PDT

wheres your advanced math?
yikes 36 casualties out of a possible 50?
and 15/20?

  • 03.06.2011 8:08 PM PDT

MJB

like i said in an earlier post, the whole fight can be reduced to one simple factor, range of combat, jedi have the close range advantage, spartans have the long range advantage, and elites would have the middle range advantage.

  • 03.06.2011 8:18 PM PDT

Force powers cans have pretty long range, like saber throwing, force pushing, etc.

Do you think the two jedi could take on all 5 of them at close range at the same time, even the Arbiter with a sword?

  • 03.07.2011 9:11 AM PDT

I put the laughter in manslaughter

If the spartan manages to aim at a Jedi, they die, simple as that.
Lightsabers can deflect a few laser rounds, but if you slap your sword at a bullet, your just going to get a nice shower of molten metal in your face.

  • 03.07.2011 9:24 AM PDT

Online Gaming's pretty much like a zombie movie. There are a lot of mindless idiots roaming around but you find some survivors on the way.
My YouTube channel
If you're interested in vs threads, here's a sweet little group for you to join


Posted by: mojeda101
It would make more sense if it was between an Elite and Jedi.

Elites would most likely come close but end up winning.
The Force is something that the Jedi has but it wouldn't do much good. Jedi masters can barely lift an X-wing that is around a ton. An Elite is hardly any different.

Lets look at characteristics.

Elites
Height: 8'6
Strength: Kill in one simple punch or kick
Weight: 800 Pounds
Weaponry: Energy Sword and Energy Dagger

Jedi
Height: 6'0
Strength: Weak
Weight: 140 Pounds
Weaponry: Lightsaber

Lets say he gets the Elite and pulls him to him to be cut with the Lightsaber, Elites are much smarter than that and would take down the Jedi with him pulling out his dagger and stabbing him as he is getting stabbed.

Although this is very debatable. A Sword would come in contact with a Lightsaber and react just like another lightsaber. Another the Elite can extend much farther.

I'm putting my money on the Elites, just by sheer statistics.




Im sorry but that is just wrong wrong wrong.
*cracks knuckles* right
1) The force wouldnt be good? are you effin serious? Ye obviously the force cant manipulate the strength speed and agility of a jedi, nor can it control minds and create lightning from your fingertips either.

2) You obviously have not got a bloody clue about star wars canon. Luke wasnt even a padawan he was an initiate. Also he didnt lift the X-Wing it was yoda and hes like 900 years old.

3) Youre saying an Elite weighs as much as an X-wing? What kind of freaking Elite are you thinking of? You know what? I dont want to know.

Also your characteristics are way off. The jedi consist of many different species. And i can assure you, not all of them are 140 pounds.

Right your second post:
I never said 800IB was a ton. Where did I say that? You think a Jedi can lift massive weights with the force? Force Unleashed is not canon. A Master can barely lift a stack that was about to crush Anakin and Obi Wan. Its obvious a knight or Padawan is MUCH weaker.
AHAHAHAHAHA... *cough* ahem. There are records of padawans stopping battle cruisers form crashing onto a planet for christ sake. Honestly what master are you talking about here? Some lard bucket Twil'ek or something?

Seriously you must have been watching and reading completely different star wars canon that the rest of the world has been for the past 30 years.

[Edited on 03.07.2011 12:11 PM PST]

  • 03.07.2011 12:07 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

hahahahaha, spartans would dominate the jedi. a lightsaber would never be able to cut through mjolnir armor with shields. spartans reacts in nano seconds and can run over 60km/h. a jedi could never deflect a bullet moving at 3000+ fps. not to mention spartans are super intelligent and have trained to kill since they were six years old. they would even kill the jedi without weapons, jedi are pathetic.

  • 03.07.2011 12:10 PM PDT

just fred could kill them. no way to block a spartan laser.

or just linda. kinda hard to deflect a sniper.
force would be useless at a distance in both cases.

  • 03.07.2011 12:12 PM PDT

  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • of 4