- ImmortalJoshua
- |
- Heroic Member
I started up the heated debate on whether the SPARTAN-II in the cryo tube near the end of Reach is really Linda.
I created the Moa XING avatar pic.
Also I earned the All Star nameplate with this submission to Week 14 All Stars http://www.bungie.net/images/News/Inline11/bwu_0415/art/likea boss.jpg
Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron
Posted by: ImmortalJoshua
Posted by: privet caboose
Nicole was likely bumped down to Spartan II class I status then. Yasmine was bumped down in the Encyclopedia, and every spec of detail that hinted at a class II was utterly destroyed with the Encyclopedia and Halseys Journal. They don't exist.
Ok YOU are choosing to ignore the existance of Class-II even though Bungie, 343, Frank all have said Class-II is canon. And it's not just you, most of you are ignoring this.
Nicole is a Class-II so that means that Class-II is now, again, OFFICIALLY CANON. She was conscripted at the time that Yasmine was conscripted, both are Class-II. So what if there was a -blam!- ERROR IN FoR! THERE'S SEVERAL CANON ERRORS IN THAT DAMN BOOK! HALSEY DIDN'T EVEN KNOW ABOUT THE ELITES!!
GET OVER IT, SHE'S CANON KNOW, ALONG WITH CLASS-II.
Fail rage much?
Your grasp of canon has been shown to be faulty, and you jump into theories with little if any backing. (The whole John Forge is Spartan 1).
If I remember correctly, you still haven't answered my question about how the Spartans IIs, in your theory, could exist. Mainly the why weren't they brought in for the Spartan II mission to capture a prophet, and how 70-100 Spartan II class II's could have MJOLNIR and not be mentioned.
I've seen Bungie say Class 2 was not canon. I haven't seen anybody say Class II is canon. I saw the message which sounded more like Nicole was formed from the basic idea of an actual Spartan, and Class II was NEVER confirmed to be canon.
Frankly, the proof given only implies the basic idea of Nicole is canon, maybe Nicole in entirety. There is no proof I've seen which says Class II are canon. Given the FACT that Halsey's Journal makes a CLEAR note of Class II being canceled (Least I think so, Pvt Caboose would probably know that better.), how could it exist?
The whole prophet mission and everything else has yet to be explained by 343i. Most likely in the future they will explore the Class-II in greater detail. Just like how Vociferous said, Nicole COULD be featured elsewhere but there are no current plans for that.
Also Halsey didn't know about S-IIIs, it could be possible she didn't even known about Class-II.
By Bungie and 343 both saying she's canon, therefore her bio is canon, which means that she is a Class-II which means that Class-II is canon.
I'm glad that I've "changed" the Haloverse a tad bit now. So next time we see more S-IIs, I wouldn't be suprised if 343 says they're Class-II.
End of Debate.
[Edited on 04.26.2011 10:51 PM PDT]