Bungie Universe
This topic has moved here: Subject: Who would win Clone Republic Commando or a Spartan?
  • Subject: Who would win Clone Republic Commando or a Spartan?
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • of 3
Subject: Who would win Clone Republic Commando or a Spartan?

I know there are alot of these but please don't trash this one. Im just doing this for fun. I would like to see everyones point of view. No haten!!! Keep it clean!!!

I would say it would be a draw. They both have augmentations and both are well trained. It would deffinatly be an interesting fight.

Clone Commandos are trained from birth. If they do not pass selection they are killed. They never train with dummy rounds. They are biologicaly augmented to have the genes for combat. They use lasers not bullets. There armor has shielding and can self repair.

[Edited on 05.06.2011 12:41 PM PDT]

  • 05.06.2011 12:25 PM PDT

Spartan. Hands down. Mjolnir armour has energy shields and is resistant to bullets and explosions. Clone armour can be beaten by teddy bears with stone clubs. The clones also use weaponry that is vastly inferior to the Spartan's.

[Edited on 05.06.2011 12:32 PM PDT]

  • 05.06.2011 12:31 PM PDT

"A LIE is a LIE"


- Truly intelligent and deep Black ops trailer

Yeah spartan

  • 05.06.2011 12:33 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

Posted by: Omanisat
Spartan. Hands down. Mjolnir armour has energy shields and is resistant to bullets and explosions. Clone armour can be beaten by teddy bears with stone clubs. The clones also use weaponry that is vastly inferior to the Spartan's.


We don't know about the weaponry thing for sure, aren't they laser, aka burn you just like plasma but in a lesser degree?

But I do agree the Spartan would win, Clone Commandos are not augmented in any way or form besides the whole shortened life span.

  • 05.06.2011 12:33 PM PDT

Should've predicted somebody would bring in the ewoks.

Yes, the STORMTROOPERs (not Clone commandos, whose armor actually had shielding.) got beaten by the Ewoks. This is because they were expected/geared to fight rebels, not the natives.

  • 05.06.2011 12:35 PM PDT

The commando's armor can self repair. Explain how spartan weaponry is superior to the clone's. The clone blaster is a grenade launcher/sniper rifle/assault rifle all in one package. The commando's also have form of energy shield as well. Yes Mjolner is resistant to bullets, but commandos don't use bullets, they use lasers and have an emp attachment on their guns.

  • 05.06.2011 12:36 PM PDT

As Obi-Wan stated, blasters are 'clumsy and random." The projectile they fire also travels several orders of magnitude slower then a bullet. All the Spartan would have to do is stay a godd distance away from the clone, and he could dodge any blaster fire directed at him.

  • 05.06.2011 12:37 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

Posted by: AtomicCardinal
The commando's armor can self repair. Explain how spartan weaponry is superior to the clone's. The clone blaster is a grenade launcher/sniper rifle/assault rifle all in one package. The commando's also have form of energy shield as well. Yes Mjolner is resistant to bullets, but commandos don't use bullets, they use lasers and have an emp attachment on their guns.


Do you have the technical specifications for the Clone Armor? That would help a lot in the debate.

  • 05.06.2011 12:37 PM PDT

Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron
Should've predicted somebody would bring in the ewoks.

Yes, the STORMTROOPERs (not Clone commandos, whose armor actually had shielding.) got beaten by the Ewoks. This is because they were expected/geared to fight rebels, not the natives.


As was shown throughout the movies, the armour was no better at stopping blasters then it was at stopping arrows. The Stormtroopers would have been better off ditching it entirely and wearing something with peripheral vision.

  • 05.06.2011 12:41 PM PDT


Posted by: Omanisat
As Obi-Wan stated, blasters are 'clumsy and random." The projectile they fire also travels several orders of magnitude slower then a bullet. All the Spartan would have to do is stay a godd distance away from the clone, and he could dodge any blaster fire directed at him.


I don't remember blaster bolts being so slow...

Also, he'd say that because he's a jedi, and uses a lightsaber.

  • 05.06.2011 12:41 PM PDT


Posted by: Omanisat
Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron
Should've predicted somebody would bring in the ewoks.

Yes, the STORMTROOPERs (not Clone commandos, whose armor actually had shielding.) got beaten by the Ewoks. This is because they were expected/geared to fight rebels, not the natives.


As was shown throughout the movies, the armour was no better at stopping blasters then it was at stopping arrows. The Stormtroopers would have been better off ditching it entirely and wearing something with peripheral vision.


Then again, would you rather see a tense gunfight with people dropping quickly on either side, or a gunfight with the stormtroopers just wading through?

Also, military grade weapons do more damage then a civilian one or such.

  • 05.06.2011 12:43 PM PDT


Do you have the technical specifications for the Clone Armor? That would help a lot in the debate. [/quote]

All sources are from the books and the Republic Commando Game.

  • 05.06.2011 12:43 PM PDT

I've read several things that state blasters are inherently inaccurate. As for the speed, given the fact that they can be tracked with the naked, unaided eye, that would seem to indicate they are slow. Try watching a bullet.

As for the armour, all I'm saying is if I was the Empire, I'd either spend the money to provide something functional, or abandon the concept entirely, not give them something that is less useful then a pair of BDUs.

[Edited on 05.06.2011 12:47 PM PDT]

  • 05.06.2011 12:44 PM PDT

I remember Obi-Wan saying that blasters are 'clumsy and random'. As stated before Obi-Wan is a jedi and doesn't believe in blasters. The closest comparison to a blaster round would be a tracer except a blaster round travels faster further and has more pinitration behind it. Its main source of power is energy like the weapons on covenant ships. The clips on the blaster is a battery pack.

  • 05.06.2011 12:47 PM PDT


Posted by: Omanisat
I've read several things that state blasters are inherently inaccurate. As for the speed, given the fact that they can be tracked with the naked, unaided eye, that would seem to indicate they are slow. Try watching a bullet.

As for the armour, all I'm saying is if I was the Empire, I'd either spend the money to provide something functional, or abandon the concept entirely, not give them something that is less useful then a pair of BDUs.



You can see a tracer round. All a tracer round is a bullet with some form of incindiary coating on it causing it to glow and be seen in the day and at night.

  • 05.06.2011 12:50 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:


Posted by: Omanisat
Spartan. Hands down. Mjolnir armour has energy shields and is resistant to bullets and explosions. Clone armour can be beaten by teddy bears with stone clubs. The clones also use weaponry that is vastly inferior to the Spartan's.


Storm Trooper Armour is actually quite resistant to bullets; in the rest of SW fluff it takes a lucky shot to the eyes to penetrate ith slug throwers.

As to what happened on Endor, the poor imperial bastards stationed there were fighting Ewoks. These little terrors cannonicly use force storms, shrink people, And have an artifact that can control half of the Empire. They work the 2nd hardest material In the SW universe; endor's trees, trees that can take the impact of a full speed jet bike without a scratch. The Ewoks can work these tree's with stone tools, and can lift them high into the air to use against combat walkers. And to top it all off, they wear solidified Wank!

Never underestimate the Endorian Horrors.


Also, the Clone Commando's blaster is leagues above what the Spartans normally carry.


In the end the Spartan could win thanks to his aguments and power armour, but this isn't exactly a huge curbstomp in his favor.

  • 05.06.2011 12:51 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

Posted by: AtomicCardinal

Do you have the technical specifications for the Clone Armor? That would help a lot in the debate. [/quote]

All sources are from the books and the Republic Commando Game.


I see, I spent this little time investigating and I've found that Clone Commando's personal shielding is only effective against blasters, so that's a negative to the fight against them, although they do have that vibroblade on their knuckle plates.

  • 05.06.2011 12:55 PM PDT

Also, the Clone Commando's blaster is leagues above what the Spartans normally carry

In terms of destructive power maybe, but it's woefully slow. Which would you rather have at 100 meters out: A blaster or a DMR?

  • 05.06.2011 12:57 PM PDT


Posted by: Omanisat
Also, the Clone Commando's blaster is leagues above what the Spartans normally carry

In terms of destructive power maybe, but it's woefully slow. Which would you rather have at 100 meters out: A blaster or a DMR?


Their blaster because it can transform into a sniper rifle in a blink of an eye.

  • 05.06.2011 1:00 PM PDT


Posted by: RKOSNAKE
Posted by: AtomicCardinal

Do you have the technical specifications for the Clone Armor? That would help a lot in the debate. [/quote]

All sources are from the books and the Republic Commando Game.


I see, I spent this little time investigating and I've found that Clone Commando's personal shielding is only effective against blasters, so that's a negative to the fight against them, although they do have that vibroblade on their knuckle plates.


I forgot about the vibroblade. Thanks for reminding me.

  • 05.06.2011 1:01 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Yes I'm fairly young. No, that doesn't mean I'm automatically dumber than you or have less life experience, thats just generally the case. I am not your general case.

Posted by: Omanisat
Spartan. Hands down. Mjolnir armour has energy shields and is resistant to bullets and explosions. Clone armour can be beaten by teddy bears with stone clubs. The clones also use weaponry that is vastly inferior to the Spartan's.

You have never seen a Clone Commando before, have you? There Katarn armour and Spartan armour isn't that different. They both have shields and are made of uber advanced materials, as well as an advanced HUD and, in the case of the clones, an active camouflage unit.

  • 05.06.2011 1:03 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Yes I'm fairly young. No, that doesn't mean I'm automatically dumber than you or have less life experience, thats just generally the case. I am not your general case.

Posted by: AtomicCardinal

Posted by: Omanisat
Also, the Clone Commando's blaster is leagues above what the Spartans normally carry

In terms of destructive power maybe, but it's woefully slow. Which would you rather have at 100 meters out: A blaster or a DMR?


Their blaster because it can transform into a sniper rifle in a blink of an eye.

He's right, you can switch from sniper, assault and grenade launcher in the blink of an eye. Their weapon system is a defined advantage over the Spartans.

  • 05.06.2011 1:05 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Yes I'm fairly young. No, that doesn't mean I'm automatically dumber than you or have less life experience, thats just generally the case. I am not your general case.

Posted by: Pewter

[quote]Posted by: Omanisat



In the end the Spartan could win thanks to his aguments and power armour, but this isn't exactly a huge curbstomp in his favor.

My thoughts exactly. He would win but not byy much.

  • 05.06.2011 1:07 PM PDT


Posted by: Pewter

Posted by: Omanisat
Spartan. Hands down. Mjolnir armour has energy shields and is resistant to bullets and explosions. Clone armour can be beaten by teddy bears with stone clubs. The clones also use weaponry that is vastly inferior to the Spartan's.


Storm Trooper Armour is actually quite resistant to bullets; in the rest of SW fluff it takes a lucky shot to the eyes to penetrate ith slug throwers.

As to what happened on Endor, the poor imperial bastards stationed there were fighting Ewoks. These little terrors cannonicly use force storms, shrink people, And have an artifact that can control half of the Empire. They work the 2nd hardest material In the SW universe; endor's trees, trees that can take the impact of a full speed jet bike without a scratch. The Ewoks can work these tree's with stone tools, and can lift them high into the air to use against combat walkers. And to top it all off, they wear solidified Wank!

Never underestimate the Endorian Horrors.


Also, the Clone Commando's blaster is leagues above what the Spartans normally carry.


In the end the Spartan could win thanks to his aguments and power armour, but this isn't exactly a huge curbstomp in his favor.


The clone's were augmented in a differnt way. Although they didn't have metal grafted on to their bones to keep them from braking, they did have their genes tampered with. They came from arguably the most leathal bounty hunter in the SW universe Jango Fett. Then the Kaminoans took his genes and tampered with them making them hyperlethal, brilliant, and resistant to severe pain. There training was deadly. No dummy round was used in their expence. It was normal for a commando to get killed in a training exercise. According to the Kaminoans this made to were the strongest survived to be put into teams if the Kaminoans didnt get to them first.

  • 05.06.2011 1:07 PM PDT
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

join Crimson Empire
Your loyalty and skill will be tested

weapons wise commando wins

augmentations and armor wise spartan wins

now if they fought i'd say the spartan'd win but barely

  • 05.06.2011 1:11 PM PDT

  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • of 3