- Devils Preists
- |
- Honorable Member
Okay Un-bias time and well even do it the way deadliest warrior does it.
For training ....Edge Spartans
For Genetic Modification/Agumentation...Edge Spartans.
Armor..Edge Clone Commando
Weapons...Edge Clone Commando
Special weapons *Melee weapons* Edge..Spartans.
In my completely un-bias opinion in this matter, A spartan could defeat a Clone commando one on one but he has a high chance of failing due to the fact, the Armor and shields of a Clone commandos armor would be deflector based if they were to work the way they do in game.
Katarn armor is indeed really really powerful stuff and could take a lot of beating.
Spartans have the Agumentations and training I agree but they'd have to take a commando's blaster and use it for a victory to be assured or get in close and attempt to disable said commando.
That being said, the shields on a spartans armor can't hold against something like a blaster for one simple reason, they are what I would consider Direct energy weapons. And I quote
"The blaster fired a highly compressed, focused high-energy particle beam that was very deadly to most creatures."
Essiently these were advanced versions of the beam rifle. Which we all know can punch right through a Spartan and Elites shields with a single shot, so imagine this adavanced Particle Beam rifle firing at a spartan.
So in the end the Spartan might not have much of a chance against a commando if it were a fire fight. Again I express a close quarters battle might end up differently.
But in the end I believe: Commando would win a firefight
and CQB A Spartan would win.
[Edited on 05.09.2011 7:40 PM PDT]