Bungie Universe
This topic has moved here: Subject: List the SPARTANS you would have in or as your own personal squad.
  • Subject: List the SPARTANS you would have in or as your own personal squad.
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • of 4
Subject: List the SPARTANS you would have in or as your own personal squad.

No u


Posted by: siggibiggy

Posted by: Cannonfodder14
List the Spartans you would have in or as your own personal squad for your own use today. The Spartans you list can be dead or alive. For example my squad would consist of the following Spartans, whom I would send to hot spots through out the world like to Pakistan to deal with the insurgency. Or to Mexico to deal with the drug problems. Note a typical squad consists from 8 to 13 soldiers.

Here is my squad.
1.John-117
2.Kelly-087
3.Linda-058 (The sniper)
4.Frederic-104
5.Grace-093 (prinicple explosives expert)
6.SPARTAN-B312 (Noble-6)
7.Kat-B320 (brilliant cryptanalyst and a hacker)
8.Adriana-111
9.Kurt-051

In addition what would you have them do?
Why do you only do (this) with the women? And why so many? It's so lame how women are seen opon these day's.

They say that they are discriminated but really what they want is to be threated different from anyone else, and in every movie and game and what have you, they can kick everyone's ass, real life, no.

On-topic, John, N6, Carter, Jorge, Fred.

That's funny, i din't know Noble six was a woman.


[Edited on 07.04.2011 12:32 PM PDT]

  • 07.04.2011 12:32 PM PDT


Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.

  • 07.04.2011 12:39 PM PDT

No u


Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.


I'm not saying any other of the Spartans couldn't have done that. I never said John was the best Spartan, because i don't think there is a best Spartan. I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt, and I think Kurt could have done what John did. What I am saying here is that John and Kurt are pretty much the same skill level in leadership. Maybe Kurt's better, maybe John is. I don't know.

And that's not why I praise John, in fact I think Kurt is awesome in the book he's in, I thought he was a hero. Besides i'm not a huge fan of six and we play as him. I'm not a huge fan of the ODSTs and we play as them. So please, don't assume I like John the most because he was who we played as in the games.

  • 07.04.2011 12:46 PM PDT

I like John more....because i dont like the games where you play as kurt.......oh wait

  • 07.04.2011 12:50 PM PDT


Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.

I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt
Tell me, what makes you think so?

  • 07.04.2011 12:53 PM PDT

I praise John because he saved the human race and he's a awesome. I like Sgt. Johnson...we dont play as him? I like emile you dont play as him. I like Cortana you dont play as her. I like the super intendent you dont play as it. i like...etc.

  • 07.04.2011 12:55 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."


Posted by: Shipley18
I praise John because he saved the human race and he's a awesome. I like Sgt. Johnson...we dont play as him? I like emile you dont play as him. I like Cortana you dont play as her. I like the super intendent you dont play as it. i like...etc.


If it wasn't for Kurt, John would have died decades before the Fall of Reach.

  • 07.04.2011 1:00 PM PDT

No u


Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.

I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt
Tell me, what makes you think so?


Well he was the highest rank of all the Spartans when they were all together, he led all of the spartans, giving commands to them even when they had split into red team, blue team, green team, etc. Also all the other Spartans listened to him and followed his orders. He commanded their respect. I believe that he could have done the same with Spartan IIIs.

Perhaps another thread should be made about this to debate it so others can stay on the subject?

EDIT: although Fhajad and Catherine were Lieutenant commanders, one is mangled beyond repair, and the other is a Spartan three. My Statement is restricted to Spartan IIs in the field. Sorry for the confusion.

[Edited on 07.04.2011 1:16 PM PDT]

  • 07.04.2011 1:03 PM PDT

No u


Posted by: RKOSNAKE

Posted by: Shipley18
I praise John because he saved the human race and he's a awesome. I like Sgt. Johnson...we dont play as him? I like emile you dont play as him. I like Cortana you dont play as her. I like the super intendent you dont play as it. i like...etc.


If it wasn't for Kurt, John would have died decades before the Fall of Reach.


That is true. I'll give Kurt that. I think Kurt is pretty great.

  • 07.04.2011 1:05 PM PDT

Plekpedia - The most epic site in the history of ever.

Kurt, John, Leonidas.

Unbeatable.

  • 07.04.2011 1:05 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."


Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.

I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt
Tell me, what makes you think so?


Well he was the highest rank of all the Spartans, he led all of the spartans, giving commands to them even when they had split into red team, blue team, green team, etc. Also all the other Spartans listened to him and followed his orders. He commanded their respect. I believe that he could have done the same with Spartan IIIs.

Perhaps another thread should be made about this to debate it so others can stay on the subject?


Kurt was a Lieutenant Commander....

  • 07.04.2011 1:06 PM PDT

No u

Yeah, I meant when they were together. Thanks for the correction.

  • 07.04.2011 1:07 PM PDT


Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.

I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt
Tell me, what makes you think so?


Well he was the highest rank of all the Spartans
Obviously you don't know what you are talking about, Kurt is the highest ranked Spartan II. John is a Master Chief Petty Officer, Kurt is a Lieutenant Commander.

There are also another few who are that rank, those being Catherine-B320 and Fhajad-084, both who are Lieutenant Commanders, although Catherine, better known as Kat, doesn't really count as she is a Spartan III, and if we put Spartan III's into count, Carter would be the highest Ranked Spartan in the argument who is a Commander.

  • 07.04.2011 1:08 PM PDT

My squad is practically perfect.

>Black-One
>Black-Two
>Black-Three

Best squad I could ever dream of.

  • 07.04.2011 1:12 PM PDT

No u

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.
Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.


Well he was the highest rank of all the SpartansObviously you don't know what you are talking about, Kurt is the highest ranked Spartan II. John is a Master Chief Petty Officer, Kurt is a Lieutenant Commander.

There are also another few who are that rank, those being Catherine-B320 and Fhajad-084, both who are Lieutenant Commanders, although Catherine, better known as Kat, doesn't really count as she is a Spartan III, and if we put Spartan III's into count, Carter would be the highest Ranked Spartan in the argument who is a Commander.


You are correct. That was when they were together, and i was talking about Spartan IIs, and Kurt was a Lieutenant commander, but i was talking about when they were all together. And about Fhajad-he wasn't an active Spartan, he worked as an analyst, etc. However, your point remains valid as i was incorrect in my statement before.

[Edited on 07.04.2011 1:13 PM PDT]

  • 07.04.2011 1:12 PM PDT


Posted by: Doctor Jensen
Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.[/quote]Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.[/quote]
I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt[/quote]Tell me, what makes you think so?[/quote]

Well he was the highest rank of all the Spartans
Obviously you don't know what you are talking about, Kurt is the highest ranked Spartan II. John is a Master Chief Petty Officer, Kurt is a Lieutenant Commander.

There are also another few who are that rank, those being Catherine-B320 and Fhajad-084, both who are Lieutenant Commanders, although Catherine, better known as Kat, doesn't really count as she is a Spartan III, and if we put Spartan III's into count, Carter would be the highest Ranked Spartan in the argument who is a Commander.


You are correct. That was when they were together, and i was talking about Spartan IIs, and Kurt was a Lieutenant commander, but i was talking about when they were all together. And about Fhajad-he wasn't an active Spartan, he worked as an analyst, etc. However, your point remains valid as i was incorrect in my statement before.
Although it's not really fair in my argument, Kurt is that rank becuase he trained the Spartan III's. John could easily be that rank although he's always alone, he doesn't know his team is alive, he never got to train the Spartan III's. He will be promoted some day after he returns to Earth after he confronted his destiny.

  • 07.04.2011 1:14 PM PDT

No u


Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen
John didn't have the chance to lead armies. Give him the chance and he would have done just as well. Perhaps better.[/quote]Don't give me that. John wasn't the best Spartan, he was just lucky, you praise him becuase you play as him, if there was no Halo series and it was based around Kurt on Onyx, you would praise him, but don't praise John just becuase you play as him in a game. Any other Spartan would have done the job better at saving the Galaxy if they were in the position John was in, John was just an Average Spartan who was lucky and always wanted to win with great skills in Assault, Kurt was a born leader who would have kept his Marines alive in any situation.

Linda, Kelly, Fred, Kurt, and Will would have pulled through what John did on the Ark easily.[/quote]
I just think that John could have trained the Spartan IIIs like Kurt[/quote]Tell me, what makes you think so?[/quote]

Well he was the highest rank of all the Spartans
Obviously you don't know what you are talking about, Kurt is the highest ranked Spartan II. John is a Master Chief Petty Officer, Kurt is a Lieutenant Commander.

There are also another few who are that rank, those being Catherine-B320 and Fhajad-084, both who are Lieutenant Commanders, although Catherine, better known as Kat, doesn't really count as she is a Spartan III, and if we put Spartan III's into count, Carter would be the highest Ranked Spartan in the argument who is a Commander.


You are correct. That was when they were together, and i was talking about Spartan IIs, and Kurt was a Lieutenant commander, but i was talking about when they were all together. And about Fhajad-he wasn't an active Spartan, he worked as an analyst, etc. However, your point remains valid as i was incorrect in my statement before.
Although it's not really fair in my argument, Kurt is that rank becuase he trained the Spartan III's. John could easily be that rank although he's always alone, he doesn't know his team is alive, he never got to train the Spartan III's. He will be promoted some day after he returns to Earth after he confronted his destiny.


Yeah, I assume that once John gets home (if he ever does) that he will be promoted. I also think that Kurt was an exceptional Spartan, and that they made the right choice for him to train the Spartan IIIs. He was an exceptional leader, maybe better than MC, but i don't know.

  • 07.04.2011 1:18 PM PDT

1.me
2.master chief
3.the arbiter
4.sgt johnson
5.my friend(sure shot ben is his gamertag)
6.spartan 1337.

  • 07.04.2011 1:30 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."

John was promoted to Master Chief Petty Officer of The Navy after Halo 3 if I'm not mistaken.

  • 07.04.2011 2:22 PM PDT


Posted by: RKOSNAKE

Posted by: Shipley18
I praise John because he saved the human race and he's a awesome. I like Sgt. Johnson...we dont play as him? I like emile you dont play as him. I like Cortana you dont play as her. I like the super intendent you dont play as it. i like...etc.


If it wasn't for Kurt, John would have died decades before the Fall of Reach.



True but we dont thank FDR's Mom for not sitting on him as a kid, ...but we'll have to agree that i'm right... i mean to disagree.

  • 07.04.2011 5:51 PM PDT

Also I feel Master Chief will always be a master chief as long as he is alive...only in death would they be able to advance his rank. The main reason being it would be wierd to call him anything but MC.

  • 07.04.2011 5:56 PM PDT

Sup, I'm Vette. My online name is usually Corvette19, so if you see me at another website, that's my name. I first started playing Halo when I was in the 4th grade, now I've graduated. I believe that was 2002-2003? Anyways, I've been with Halo for a long time. I mod Halo PC/CE so just hit me up if you want to. My Xfire=Corvette19. That's all I can say pretty much..


Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101

Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: mojeda101
1. Kurt
2. Linda
3. Kelly
4. Fred
5. Will
6. Jorge
7. Cal
8. Jai
9. Vinh
10. Isaac

No Master Chief, he sucks =]
In My Opinion, Kurt is a much more suitable leader when it comes to controlling troops.


I don't think so. john is a stronger leader, in fact that's why he was the original leader of the Spartans.
Then explain why Kurt's team always seemed to beat John's? =]


Honestly I have no idea. But i still hold firmly to the fact that John is better. But agree to disagree eh?
Want to know the answer? Because Kurt is better when it comes to leading troops. He lead countless Spartan III's in battle and even trained them.

John leads teams.

Kurt leads Armies.

Army > Team


John saves the galaxy
Galaxy > Army

  • 07.04.2011 6:00 PM PDT

"I may not be perfect, but always been true."


Posted by: Vette19
John saves the galaxy
Galaxy > Army


Again, if it wasn't for Kurt, the galaxy would have been doomed. He saved John from dying so...

Kurt > John

  • 07.04.2011 6:02 PM PDT

Johnson helped train the II's
Johnson>MC>all other spartans

No doubt however if Kurt was as lucky as Chief he could be the hero too.

Ever heard the saying I'd rather be lucky than good?

  • 07.04.2011 6:05 PM PDT

S.H.E


Posted by: Doctor Jensen

Posted by: siggibiggy

Posted by: Cannonfodder14
List the Spartans you would have in or as your own personal squad for your own use today. The Spartans you list can be dead or alive. For example my squad would consist of the following Spartans, whom I would send to hot spots through out the world like to Pakistan to deal with the insurgency. Or to Mexico to deal with the drug problems. Note a typical squad consists from 8 to 13 soldiers.

Here is my squad.
1.John-117
2.Kelly-087
3.Linda-058 (The sniper)
4.Frederic-104
5.Grace-093 (prinicple explosives expert)
6.SPARTAN-B312 (Noble-6)
7.Kat-B320 (brilliant cryptanalyst and a hacker)
8.Adriana-111
9.Kurt-051

In addition what would you have them do?
Why do you only do (this) with the women? And why so many? It's so lame how women are seen opon these day's.

They say that they are discriminated but really what they want is to be threated different from anyone else, and in every movie and game and what have you, they can kick everyone's ass, real life, no.

On-topic, John, N6, Carter, Jorge, Fred.

That's funny, i din't know Noble six was a woman.
No you muppet, SPARTAN-B312 meaning--> (Noble-6)
Isn't the same as Kat-B320 (brilliant cryptanalyst and a hacker).
And btw, noble six is infact a woman if you choose her/him to be that, so you sir, FAIL!

[Edited on 07.04.2011 6:38 PM PDT]

  • 07.04.2011 6:37 PM PDT

  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • of 4