Posted by: RKOSNAKE
Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron
Posted by: EpicFailMan50
Spartan II > Spartan III
Already debated and proven wrong many times.
Anyway, I choose six. Six, in a single game showed personality. Master Chief had the personality of a brick in Halo CE.
In addition, Six isn't overrated and worshiped as a god as Master chief is and shouldn't be. Spartan II's as a whole have become overrated and boring now.
Posted by: ThePredkiller2
Posted by: SEAL Sniper 9
Master Chief...by far.
Six doesn't even compare.
Your Noble Six, or the canon? Because my Noble Six could wipe the floor and his ass with Master Chief. Lieutenant David-B312 (mine) has single handedly defeated thirteen SPARTAN-IIs, and dozens of Elite Generals, by himself, before falling because he was racked with the guilt of killing his SPARTAN brothers. My reasoning for this backstory is that... well, the SPARTANS are all dead on the final mission, yet no Covenant bodies. The only one who could've killed them was Noble Six (mine, dunno about yours).
Oh, and to add to that list, has personally assisted in the assassination of a Sangheili Field Marshall who was backed by Zealots (Master Chief killed Regret who was guarded by the much less disciplined Honor Guards), as well as assisted in the destruction of a Covenant Supercarrier, has Master Chief? No. His biggest kill is an Assault Carrier, which is dwarfed by a Supercarrier many times over.
David-B312 >>> John-117
As for canon Noble Six, I'd say Master Chief wins, but against my Noble Six? Hell no.
This concludes my discussion.
For those two reasons I chose Six. We can have Six be whatever we want, and even when we first meet him he has more personality than John has in the trilogy games.
Another thing, since you can equip Six with any armor you please, I am sure with the right equipment, Six could simply overrun Master Chief with his inferior "default" armor with relative ease. I'm not sure, correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't GUNGNIR a super-secret ONI program designed to make the ultimate power armor or something like that? Wrong or not, Six has the guns, equipment, and armor to make Master Chief his plaything. Another armor I'm sure would give him an edge is the Grenadier chestpiece (Jorge's armor), the generator (on his chest) would most likely double his shields to that of Chief's, meaning he could keep going long after Master Chief had retreated to lick his wounds.
[Edited on 07.07.2011 10:13 PM PDT]