- Onyx81
- |
- Veteran Legendary Member
Don't be stupid like I was! Check to see what that Forum Ninja is saying to you!
"I may not like what you say, but I will defend your right to the death to say it!"
"Tolerance is a virtue, and virtue builds character."
-Onyx81
Posted by: BlueRuby2k10
Posted by: grey101
Posted by: BlueRuby2k10
Just saying now that I've layed out all of my points in the thread, so I'm good for now.
I'm not trying to change you guys' minds, (I know I couldn't if I tried my very hardest) I just wanted to point out this undeniable fallacy in the story of the game. There were too many flashing possibilites (as all of us pointed out in our conversation) for Cortana's plan to be considered "foolproof". Though, perhaps Cortana never intended for it to be, instead relying on Chief's supposed "luck", but that's a stretch too far, eh?
normally when a group of people say "you are wrong" it is normally correct, same as this case.
There would be nothing logical nor strategic for the gravemind to just run for no reason.
Um now I might be wrong here but i don't see how a fallacy is connected to the game. if anything there are more fallacies in some of the arguments here (which i find funny how you mentioned it), which fallacy does the game follow if i might ask?
You contradicted yourself. You're saying the Gravemind isn't the smartest one, but then you make mention of logic and strategy.
If you just open your mind, it's quite clear that the part of the game I'm pointing out really requires more explaining.
For now, I'm going to make my own explanation by saying that Cortana (or Johnson) jammed the Frigate's controls until Chief gave her control of it. Still, the Flood could have potentially hacked the controls, but I don't think they'd have time to find out how to do all of that before Chief and Arbiter got there to reclaim it. (I know I'm contradicting a statement in my OP. Editing.)
But one more thing comes to mind. If Flood didn't take control of the ship, then they could have hid on it. However, Cortana would have detected them anyway, so that's ruled out. Did you not read my reply? Sure he may be extremely smart, but without his physical body, he can't stop anything himself. Also, again, there were thousands of sentinels so I doubt he or his combat forms could have goten past them. could have gotten