- ROBERTO jh
- |
- Fabled Heroic Member
Posted by: Xd00999
Posted by: ROBERTO jh
ajw, if you'll so kindly come over to the other thread that you must have gotten this information from (because it surely wasn't the book) you'll learn the OP of that thread trolled the -blam!- out of the universe forum. I just finished the book; virtually nothing he said was true.
You did not do the research. Ajw made this thread at 10:53 am. Salty made his thread at 12 am, almost an hour later. Unless Ajw really is the Doctor he did not get his info from Salty.
Damn then, my bad (I was kind of heated up at the moment too, what with all the bogus info getting tossed around (and I hate bs info more then anything), but still). Ajw seems unlikely, at least imo, to be the kind of person to through around totally false info for the sake of trolling.
Where did you get that info then, ajw? Becauase again, you definitely didn't get it from the book.
Edit:
Posted by: ajw34307
Posted by: Cmdr DaeFaron
Posted by: Xd00999
Posted by: ROBERTO jh
ajw, if you'll so kindly come over to the other thread that you must have gotten this information from (because it surely wasn't the book) you'll learn the OP of that thread trolled the -blam!- out of the universe forum. I just finished the book; virtually nothing he said was true.
You did not do the research. Ajw made this thread at 10:53 am. Salty made his thread at 12 am, almost an hour later. Unless Ajw really is the Doctor he did not get his info from Salty.
Might be boasting, but AJW actually got the idea from me If I think correctly.
I read about the Spartans gaining family info, then posted a rough idea of how it'd backfire against ONI if used a certain way. Later, AJW posts this topic.
He can clear it up though.
Also, I don't see why she would do this. Because A: The spartans wouldn't remember their family possibly, or wouldn't be comfortable going back. B: Family wouldn't accept them most likely. and C: They wouldn't feel like they owe her anything.
Hell, I was stunned when the one guy read the files, and hated Halsey but was A-okay with ONI afterwards.
You're correct, I didn't pick this up immediately from the novel but when DaeFaron posted his ideas about the ramifications and how retarded ONI were I decided to post this here.
Well that at least proves there's still some sanity here. I admit I needed to do my research a bit better though, but I guess that's what happens when you feel you've been lied too... >.>
Anyway, I believe Parangosky allowed the Spartans to read the files (and again, only if they wanted too, she didn't make them read it) because Naomi had seen Halsey's journal and therefore knew enough to get her to wonder but not enough for it to be a closed book in her case (and therefore was allowed to read her file by Osman). Trying to be fair to the other Spartans possibly; at least now they have options.
But they won't turn on ONI, they have to much invested on ONI and the UNSC--as in their lives--to even think about it. Parangosky would have made doubly sure that the Spartans' psyche was ready to know about their families before making the move.
[Edited on 10.27.2011 4:39 AM PDT]