- grey101
- |
- Fabled Mythic Member
- gamertag: [none]
- user homepage:
Deva Path
Posted by: DecepticonCobra
We are all going to get banned aren't we?
Posted by: HipiO7
Posted by: grey101
I am asking where it was said the entire planet was devastated by the ring and then explained in detail the effects of that firing. Um, that goes for the entire galaxy the san shyuum on JanJur Qom would have been able to live on that planet after the firing.
You seriously can't say 343 made a mistake for something you can't understand and an event that wasn't explained in detail.
I think it's understood when it said the species was nearly exterminated, that the planet itself was was devastated. I doubt the Halo detonation was limited since Faber wanted to test it's capabilities on living intelligent beings, thinking the Prophet Rebellion had given him the perfect excuse.
I'm saying the planet was bombarded and all major cities dismantled by Builder Security. Add to that the Halo detonation and I'm pretty sure the planet was completely in a ecological collapse. The planet being a wasteland from what is told on the Bestiarium can kind of tell the planet couldn't regenerate after these events.
Yes, there is a lack of information here, obviously, but you can put the pieces together enough to pretty much understand that the full picture isn't right.
I just re-read those chapters again and nothing was said about the San shyuum nearly being exterminated and it was said
It slowly became obvious that the decimation of the San'Shyuum world was not all
one-sided. The planet itself was a source of plasma pulses and other firepower.
Meaning the San Shyuum were fighting back and as for this
"I saw the planet being devastated. I saw a great ring lit by the sun on one side.
Perhaps I imagined it."
Means " I saw the planet being attacked and i saw a halo" nothing was we don't have an account of the ring firing on the planet what was described was the uprising. All the destruction happened prior to the ring showing up and that chapter then ended and the next started with Faber questioning everybody.
You are exaggerating the events that happened and are filling in the gaps with your own interpretation. Can i get a source saying that is why Fabre fired the ring on Janjur Qom? Because from what we know in the book he was acting so rash because he was stressed/freaking out because mendicant bias ran off with the captive.
your "pretty sure" isn't factual and this is your problem not 343's. It was made clear by bornstellars father-who created the rings, that the tuning had been changed at charum hakkor and it wasn't suppose to completely obliterate the planet. The rings normal tuning only kills those that are or can be infected not everything down to a bacterial level.
Are we sure these are the events the beasturim is referring to? I would also like to remind you that Janur Qom is the main shan shyumm planet out of 3 so your idea of "they were nearly exterminated" is flawed since we know they were living on the other two planets along with the forerunners using one for storage.
Obviously you painting that picture yourself was in error.