Well...
Based on recent visits and observations.
Those people there are really... adamant.
The game, which is frankly still very good (Campaign, Spartan Ops, maybe Multiplayer).. Has issues that they either A) refuse to acknowledge it B) Dont care C) Everything is okay.
Halo 4 has its good sides and the bad sides which falls deaf on the eyes. It could improve the experience not just for a certain group, but for everyone.
Changes like, theater for campaign fellas, nerf a few thngs (BS, DMR (this is very debatable), remove killcams, remove or fix JIP, more Custom options, etc..
They even denied for an option to disable Sprint. "AN OPTION because they think ITS FOR COMPETITIVE PLAYERS??? NOOOOO!!!!"
And they have the mind set, competitive=bad. Its not really for competitive..more options=better.
[Edited on 11.29.2012 6:29 AM PST]