- theHurtfulTurkey
- |
- Fabled Mythic Member
**Devil's advocate of the Flood. My posts may or may not represent my personal opinion, I just enjoy disagreeing with people. None of my posts are representative of the official view of the Navy or any government agency.
Non Sibi Sed Patriae
Homework questions? Forget the Flood, join The Academy.
I've got a fan!
Posted by: ninjakenzen
Posted by: theHurtfulTurkey
Posted by: ninjakenzen
Posted by: theHurtfulTurkey
Not to mention that Ras' goal was fulfilled after TDK when the police ran out the mob and basically eliminated the Gotham underworld. So Talia was just redundant and unnecessary. Nothing they did make sense, and it's annoying how lazy the plot was.
Also, nuclear reactors cannot turn into nuclear bombs.
Not to forget that this is a super-hero movie where Batman exist and as grounded and realistic as the movie tries to be, it is always a movie first.
People who try to compare it to reality and make points that is inconsistent with reality therefore= bad movie, just do not get it. That, it's done with entertainment purposes in mind not a live re-enactment done with scientific scale to please the nerdy critics who like to compare realistic accuracy.
Then Nolan probably shouldn't have given it such a gritty and realistic feel to it. It's not at all nerdy to Google the question "can nuclear reactors explode?" and realize that the entire plot is nullified by the answer "no, as a matter of fact, they can't explode because that would be stupid".
-The villains' motives don't make sense
-The timeline doesn't make sense
-Bruce's depression doesn't make sense (because it's directly related to his awesome reactor becoming a bomb)
-The prison doesn't make sense
-Batman's lack of fighting abilities don't make sense
-WURRR IS DA TRIGGAAA
When Nolan worked so hard in the Batman Begins to give this Batman series a believable setting grounded in reality that people could relate to, he did it specifically so that people wouldn't have to walk away from his movie saying "oh, well that part of the plot was stupid but it's okay because it's just a superhero movie", and TDKR was a disgrace.
See this is the bit where you want me to argue that it does make sense.
But I'm just going to say Batman in general does not make sense. Why do you pick and choose what you want to believe in the story?
The villains motives did not make sense?
I'm sorry but did we watch the same movie? Talia is Ra's daughter, she wanted to finish what her father had started. Bain was just a loyal guard. His motive's lied with whatever Talia's motives were.
The timeline does not make sense?
Movie=ruined. This is so essential to the plot right, we must know every minute of every second in this fictional world to acept this is a good movie. Why is this even an issue? I would understand if this was to a large extent that it did not make sense but it's a very little thing that only affects consistency of the movie. Petty argument point.
Bruce's depression doesn't make sense?
Okay fine it doesn't, I'm not here to defend Bruce.
Movie is ruined.
Batman lacks fighting skills?
Okay. What is there to say? He did. So this is a contributing factor to a terrible movie because Batman has less fighting skills?
Where is the trigger?
If i say up your bumhole does it make it any better? because for all we know Nolan could have very well written that in his script.So bad movie.
Nolan tried to make a grounded movie, as much as he could. However I'm sure he knew that no matter how grounded it would be/ how believable it could be. It is always going to be flawed realistically because this is a world where Batman exists.
I really am finding so hard to grasp that people who want to critique these movies for every inch of disbelief, forgot that they are not analyzing Historic Primary Sources, but fictional works of entertainment.
How about you people learn to respond without acting like children and throwing around insults?
Talia's motive: She wanted to finish what her father started: destroy Gotham because it was infested with villainy. Okay, the cops and Batman did that during and after TDK. Problem solved. No more mob.
Timeline: Did I ask for specifics? No, but stuff like "how did Batman get home in one day from a hole in the ground he just climbed out of?", "how long was Batman in the prison?", etc.
Apparently you don't enjoy analyzing the media you consume, so why are you even in this thread?