- Officer Nasty16
- |
- Heroic Member
Posted by: Kendzierski7
Posted by: Officer Nasty16
Posted by: Kendzierski7
AP if those are my only choices. Rodgers and Brady both deserve it more than Manning though.
Rodgers and Brady definitely do not deserve it more than Peyton. Look at the teams they're on and the receivers they throw to, having multiple Pro-Bowlers on their offense. Now, look at Peyton, making household names out of receivers like Demaryius Thomas and Eric Decker.What other probowlers are on the Packers' offense? I think only Saturday, and he doesn't even deserve to be on there.
Thomas and Decker were already having decent seasons in the past few years with the likes of Tebow and Orton throwing to them. Obviously Peyton will help them put up better stats than Tebow will but they're still really good receivers no matter what.
And if you are gonna say that it was Peyton who made household names out of Decker and Thomas, then I have to mention that Rodgers made household names out of James Jones and Cobb while his other two starters were injured for the better part of this season. And Rodgers is doing it with (arguably) the worst OL in the league and a poor run game.
Edit: I'd probably give AP the slight edge over all of them though, especially if he manages to break the record, so it doesn't really matter I guess.
Greg Jennings has been in a Pro Bowl and Jordy Nelson was in it last year. You're right though, Jennings has basically been injured the whole season, and Nelson hasn't been as good and was also injured for a while, too.